A woman shaping a slightly uneven clay bowl on a pottery wheel, with a small smile

The voice that says you are too much or not enough

The inner voice that calls you too much or not enough, and where it learned to talk that way.

Request a Free Consultation

Guides/Self-Esteem and Boundaries

You sent the proposal, and the voice started before the email left your outbox: "That was sloppy. They are going to see through you." At dinner it said you talked too much. When you got quiet, it said you were boring. It has commented on your day, every day, for as long as you can remember, in a tone you would never use with another person.

How the Critic Talks

The critic has a recognizable style. It speaks in absolutes: always, never, everyone. It sounds like fact instead of opinion. Most women I work with have stopped hearing it as a voice at all. It has become the background, like a radio left on in another room.

Too Much and Not Enough at Once

One thing I point out early is that the critic contradicts itself. You are too loud and too quiet. Too ambitious and not accomplished enough. If the standard moves every time you approach it, the standard was never the point. A voice that cannot be satisfied is doing something other than giving feedback.

Where It Learned That Tone

Nobody is born talking to herself this way. The tone was picked up somewhere. Sometimes it is close to a direct quote from a parent, a teacher, an older sibling, or a kitchen full of relatives who commented freely. Sometimes no one said it out loud, and you absorbed it from what earned praise and what earned silence.

A useful question is: whose voice is this, and how old was I when I first heard it? Many women answer faster than they expect.

A woman reading on a sunlit porch with a cup of coffee

What It Thinks It Is Doing for You

Odd as it sounds, the critic usually believes it is helping. Its logic goes: if I say it first, it hurts less when someone else does. If I keep you sharp, nobody catches you off guard. Many accomplished women fear that without it they would get lazy or careless. As I see it, the drive is yours, and the critic has been taking credit for it.

Writing Down Its Exact Words

For three days, catch the critic in writing. Use its precise wording, in quotation marks, with the time and what you were doing. On paper, "You always ruin things" at 9:15 after a typo looks different than it sounded in your head. You begin to see how repetitive it is, and how little its volume has to do with the size of the mistake.

A Second Voice, Not a Louder One

Arguing with the critic rarely works, and neither do cheerful slogans you do not believe. What I suggest is adding a second voice that is simply accurate. After "That was sloppy," try: "There was one typo. The proposal was solid, and I sent it on time." It feels flat at first, which is fine.

How We Work With the Critic

In sessions we get to know this voice instead of trying to silence it. Psychodynamic work lets us find out what it was guarding when it first appeared. CBT gives us a way to check its claims against the facts of your week. And I keep pointing to what you do well, because the critic leaves that out. This is central to my work on self-esteem and boundaries. If comparison is the critic's favorite tool, see comparing yourself to everyone else.

If the Voice Turns Dark

For some people the criticism goes beyond harsh, into thoughts that they are a burden or should not be here. If that is where yours goes, please do not wait for a therapy appointment. Call or text 988, or call 911. My practice is not set up for emergencies.

You have listened to that voice for a long time. If you would like someone to listen to you instead, request a free 15-minute consultation and tell me what it said this week.

Request a Free Consultation

This guide is general education. It is not therapy, a diagnosis or medical advice, and reading it does not create a psychologist-client relationship. Questions about physical symptoms, hormones or medication belong with your medical provider.

A woman sitting on the steps of a hillside home, looking out over a canyon

Free 15-Minute Consultation

Make room for your own needs

Request a short call to ask questions and see whether we are a good fit.

Request a Free Consultation
Contact